One of the
most frustrating things that evangelicals, especially those influenced by
modern American and end times evangelicalism (which is many modern Baptists,
Pentecostals, Charismatics, independent churches, etc, etc) do is whenever
there is a new technology revealed, they instantly start arguing that this is
the beast’s tool to build the beasts system and the beast will use this
technology to control us all.
I have been
around long enough to see this thinking applied to everything from things like
barcodes, to credit-cards, to mobile phones, to bitcoin and more. The big one
that this thinking is now being applied to is AI.
But now that
it is becoming
increasingly clear that AI is going to turn out to fall far short of the Big
Tech Bro predictions, as it always was, again the evangelical church is
going to have egg on its face. The tech bros were always simply trying to
upsell their product, which is why they sold it to people in the apocalyptic
world changing terms they did. Many of the predictions, made by evangelicals,
about AI being the final key to the antichrist system will again make the evangelical
church look ridiculous. We have to be better guys, much better.
AI is
becoming slightly more useful with every update. But every big tech company is
also haemorrhaging money quickly, because achieving that rise of utility is being outweighed by the cost of the infrastructure needed to get those gains, and not enough revenue to offset those costs.
In other words, the AI tech companies are increasing their debt, to outcompete each
other, but they are not able to bring in enough money to cover those debts. On
top of this the tech base they are relying on to produce the computing power is
quickly perishing. Graphics cards in data centres don't last as long as people
think, only a few years. You might still be able to use your 1080 TI to run Steam games on medium settings in a rig you bought 10 years ago, but AI data centres
run 24/7 at a high output, that chews through the technology they rely on.
Hence, the costs of improving AI are increasing and the returns are not
increasing fast enough. AI investment is heading for a big downturn.
This does not
mean AI won’t have its uses. Look at how Castalia House is using it to
produce new translations of books on a daily basis. There are other ways it can
be used as a research assistant, to speed up code writing, to increase the
writing output for talented writers, and in many other ways. But it also gets
things wrong often, and needs a lot of oversight, correction and direction.
In other
words, AI will just turn out to be a very useful personal assistance tool, that
people will only trust with certain tasks, because we have all seen how
unreliable it can be in a host of circumstances. Even the ways it is being used in
law enforcement are coming under scrutiny and causing legal cases because
AI is shown often to be unreliable, resulting in many fines being overturned in reviews.
Already we
see a lot of people mock AI content as inferior. Who here even bothers to read
a post on social media, or in a blog, once you work out that the person wrote
it with AI? You skip it, don’t you. I do. Most people who use AI also won't pay
for it, and so the companies are building liabilities they cannot cover, on a
technology that many people are having bad experiences with. It will improve
over time, but it is not going to be the omniscient danger many have predicted
it to be.
Don't get me
wrong, I agree with people who are concerned with how modern governments are
using technology to strip away our rights, freedoms and privacy. Be ever
vigilant and vocal about that.
But the key
to the antichrist system is not a technology, it is a spirit which, 1) seeks to
take the place of the Lord Jesus, 2) seeks to deny the true Lord Jesus, 3)
convinces people to worship it and offer their lives to it. Tech is not
required for that. Versions of this antichrist spirit and system existed in the
1st century, and have in every century since.
Christians
have to stop automatically assuming every new technology is the beast’s
technology. Technology is basically morally neutral. It is the heart of man
that can direct it towards evil or towards good. You can use AI to create an incredible
worship song for the Lord or you can use it for nefarious purposes. It is
the heart of mankind that is the real issue, along with the spiritual realm of
darkness.
There are
antichrists everywhere. By that I mean that there are people everywhere who deny Christ and
proclaim false religions in the place of his true religion. Be more on guard
for that. In fact, that is our bigger concern, and that kind of evil has always
been pervasive in our world.
Interestingly,
the tech moguls kind of are treated by many people like modern deities, or at
least demi-gods, who will lead us into the promise land of the future tech utopia.
Many of them have obviously believed their own hype, and so the massive fall of
much of their industry is exactly what we should expect. And that tech
depression is coming. In fact, it is likely already here. Pride comes before a
massive fall. They thought the key to creating intelligence was ram and ever
increasing CPU power. But that is just the key to burning through electricity
fast and churning out slop videos and photos. Intelligence is created by a Higher Intelligence, and he looks at the pride of man and laughs (cf. Psalm 2).
This does not
mean that AI won't be of use. It will be very useful for some applications. It
does not mean it won't take away some jobs, it will, as all disruptive technologies
do. But like all other tech it will not achieve all of what was promised, it
will fall short of its makers claims, and it will turn out to be a pretty
mundane thing in a few years, that many people have incorporated into their
everyday life.
Beware the
constant “is this the antichrist tech” thinking. Be more concerned about how
sinful politicians and sinful tech barons can use any technology to push
autocratic ends. That is something to be vigilant of. But then that issue has existed
long before silicone was transformed in such a way that helped the rocks
cry out.
