Has Standing
With Israel Blessed America (Part 5)
“But whoever causes one of these
little ones who believe in Me to sin, it would be better for him if a millstone
were hung around his neck, and he were drowned in the depth of the sea.”
Matthew 18:6
Christians
are being persecuted in Syria. No, it is worse, they are being massacred,
“Christians
and other religious minorities have been massacred in Syria as violence erupts
following the overthrow of President Bashar al-Assad three months ago.
More
than 1,000 people have been killed since Thursday in what observers describe as
the worst violence since Assad's downfall in December.
The
killings have targeted Alawites, Christians and other minorities in Syria's
coastal regions.
The
violence began with an ambush on a Syrian security patrol by gunmen loyal to
ousted leader Assad near the port city of Latakia.[1]
This violence
on behalf of Islamic Jihadists is rightly making many Christians angry.
Christians have long been persecuted in the Middle East. The way the Ottoman
Empire kidnapped the best children of the Christian families and turned them
into warriors for the Islamic Emperors is infamous. From the moment that Islam
broke out of Arabia onto the World stage it has gone to war with Christians
beginning with the Eastern Roman Empire, and has often since targeted those who
professed Jesus as Lord. This is a conflict that has gone on for centuries.
So, I agree
with all the Christians and other westerners 100% that we need to fight Islamic
terrorism. We just should not be fighting it how we have been doing it, because
we are making it far worse.
In this
series I have previously written about how America’s alliance with Israel has
stoked up constant war in the Middle East. These two countries have egged each
other on into conflict after conflict. I even mentioned in my previous post how
the Christians in Syria will suffer the most from the US and Israeli success in
toppling Assad’s region. But this bears more attention, because America, the
West, and especially Christian Zionists, bear great responsibility for how
terribly the war on terror has gone, and how this has adversely affected our
fellow believers in the Middle East, and spread increased terrorism to the
West.
For instance,
the claim is often made about Islamic terrorism that we need to fight them
there (in the Middle East) so that we do not have to fight them here (in the
West). But are you aware that every time the US and Israel go to war with a
Muslim country, this sends an influx of mass Islamic immigration into the West?
For instance,
many westerners are aware that in 2015 there was an influx of over 1 million
people from the Middle East, and north Africa into Europe. Many Christians at
the time, I remember, I was among them, were calling for European nations to
stop this influx into the West. Many westerners were correctly tolling the bell
and warning about the disasters this would bring on Europe. All you need do is look
at the tragedies that happen in German Christmas markets every year, where cars
are often used as weapons, and the plethora of other issues that this has
brought into Europe to recognize the people warning about this were right.
But many
people calling for this influx to stop, refused and still often today refuse, to
recognize that it was US and Israeli military campaigns in the Middle East that
caused this mass Exodus,
“The
conflict in Syria continues to be by far the biggest driver of migration. But
the ongoing violence in Afghanistan and Iraq, abuses in Eritrea, as well as
poverty in Kosovo, are also leading people to look for new lives elsewhere…
…Although
not all of those arriving in Europe choose to claim asylum, many do. Germany
received the highest number of new asylum applications in 2015, with more than
476,000.
But
far more people have arrived in the country - German officials said more than a
million had been counted in Germany's "EASY" system for counting and
distributing people before they make asylum claims.”[2]
How many
people remember that there was mass pressure from the public and media at the
time to arm the rebels to “fight for democracy” in this Syrian conflict?
“Because
of the uprising, Syria was in the news. But despite the changes within the
country, Syria still wasn't vital to the strategic interests of the US. For
that reason it remained a low priority for administration officials.
When
the Assad regime started to falter in 2012, Ford believed the US should get
involved in the conflict by supporting the rebels. Otherwise Syria could slide
into anarchy and become "another Somalia/Yemen", he said, using state
department code for Failed State.
Virtually
everyone in the US, including Obama, wanted to support the opposition in Syria.”[3]
Even Tony
Abbott, had warned us in 2013 that the situation in Syria was baddies verse
baddies, and warned about getting involved.[4] This BBC article above actually
questions how effective the US support of the Syrian rebels was, and argues it
was largely an ineffective failure. But the history does not end there, Biden
settled the question on whether the US and Israel were involved in the toppling
of Assad in 2024,
“After
Syrian opposition forces led an offensive that rapidly swept through Syria's
major cities in a matter of weeks and ultimately led to the fall of Bashar
al-Assad's government, US President Joe Biden publicly took credit for the
rebel takeover.
"Our
approach has shifted the balance of power in the Middle East," Biden said
earlier this week.
"Through
this combination of support for our partners, sanctions, and diplomacy and
targeted military force when necessary, we now see new opportunities opening up
for the people of Syria and for the entire region."
Biden's
comments, as well as a deluge of commentary claiming that Washington - and
Israel - were secretly behind the offensive, have caused questions to resurface
about the US's role in Syria over the past decade and a half.[5]
In fact, the
US spent one billion dollars training Syrian rebels under an operation called
“Timber Sycamore.”[6]
The US, as the article notes, was not able to control these rebels, but it sure
did unleash them. However, not until after it had trained and equipped them.
So, to talk
about Islamic terrorist attacks committed by some of those over a million
people who fled into Europe, or even the ones committed in Syria against
Christians recently, without discussing the admitted and open acknowledgement
of the US and Israel in interfering in Syria, is not the full story. Israel and
the US have been interfering in the Middle East and training radicals under the
label of “freedom fighters” or “radicals” for decades. “Operation Cyclone” was
a previous example where the US trained and equipped the Afghan Mujahedeen from
1979 to 1992.[7]
This is mainstream, well understood, history and it has had incredibly negative
blowback effects.
Continued US
presence in the Middle East is a danger to western nations. Again, and again,
these conflicts stir up the Middle East, drive people out of the Middle East
and it is only the West that will take these “refugees” that flow out of war-torn
countries. The Neo-Cons and the leadership of Israel, know this, and apparently
do not care. Even now, the Australian Prime Minister has increased the annual
refugee intake to 20,000 a year, and look where the majority of these refugees
come from, “About two-thirds of all refugees come from five countries:
Afghanistan, Myanmar, Syria, South Sudan and Somalia.”[8] Afghanistan and Syria, two
places the West has been at war with, are among the top countries for refugee
intakes. These refugee crises are manufactured by American and western forever
wars.
I know many
people on the Christian right who would agree we should not be bringing more
Islamic refugees here. But many such people refuse to acknowledge how our
forever wars create the very situation that drives these people out of their
countries. The West is forced to take the aggrieved immigrants, who are angry
in large numbers at the West. This is foolishness at every end. We should be
leaving these countries alone.
I should note
that Netanyahu also took credit for handing Syria over to the radical Islamists
publicly.[9] Even Christians were
celebrating it with him last year. This is no accident. This has been part of
his plan to destabilize the Middle East since the 90s as we discussed in an
earlier peace.
“This
prediction also gives us a window through which to explain America’s disastrous
20th and early 21st century Middle Eastern
foreign policy. America has lurched from defeat to defeat in the region, with
the exception of the first Iraq war[9], largely because its Middle Eastern
policy has been Israeli centric and irrational.
Jeffrey
Sachs, economist, public policy analyst, former Harvard and current Columbia
University professor, notes,
“For
30 years the Israel Lobby has induced the U.S. to fight wars on Israel’s behalf
designed to prevent the emergence of a Palestinian State. Netanyahu, who first
came to power in 1996, and has been prime minister for 17 years since then, has
been the main cheerleader for U.S.-backed wars in the Middle East. The result
has been a disaster for the U.S. and a bloody catastrophe not only for the
Palestinian people but for the entire Middle East.
These
have not been wars to defend Israel, but rather wars to topple governments that
oppose Israel’s oppression of the Palestinian people.”[10]”
As Ilan Pappe
notes in his book Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic,
what has been at work in the Middle East for decades behind these wars is an
unrighteous alliance, “The unholy trinity of Christian Zionism,
neo-conservatism and American Jewish lobbying still had an immense impact on
legislation, elections and policies concerning Israel and Palestine.”[10] But the impact of this
alliance goes far beyond just Palestine and Israel, as Pappe also notes,
“The
Israeli government, neo-cons and Christian Zionists, all of whom AIPAC closely collaborated
with, helped make the invasion of Iraq possible and must be held responsible
for the catastrophes that followed: civil war, state collapse, the rise of
Islamic State and the ongoing refugee crisis.”[11]
“…and must be
held responsible…” for what? For “…civil war, state collapse, the rise of
Islamic state and the ongoing refugee crisis…” Scholars who pay attention to
what is happening in the Middle East are fully aware of how American and
Israeli military actions have destabilized the region. Attacks against
Christians are part of these ongoing flow on effects.
Biden took
credit for the toppling of Assad. So did Netanyahu. Both did it publicly not
secretly. Both Netanyahu, and the American Israel lobby, which is made up of
both Jewish Zionists and Christian Zionists openly advocated for these wars, as
did the leadership of Israel. In fact, Christian Zionists added an eschatological
edge to these wars,
“For
the hard core Christian Zionists, Operation Shock and Awe, the Anglo-American
assault on Iraq in April 2003, looked like a scene out of their own doomsday
scenarios. This was the wrath of the Hebrew God that was joyously received by
Christian Zionists as well as messianic Jews in Israel, who uncovered a
theological basis for the dubious links between Islam, terror and Palestine.
The old bestseller Scofield’s Bible was revived and offered a contemporary
fundamentalist reading of Old and New Testaments - interpreted to command
support for Israel as a literal article of faith.”[12]
During this
war many Christian leaders began to interpret the end times texts in light of a
war between America and Islam, as Pappe notes. I personally remember going to
conferences and hearing such teaching. I am also old enough to remember when
these same sorts of teachers said it was the Soviet Union who was the main
enemy. Though I am only just old enough, and only because I am aware of some of
their older books on the issue. Pappe even notes that the Christian Zionists
went so far as making video games to encourage young people to join the war
against Islam and to teach this theology that standing with Israel, militarily
and otherwise, is necessary to be faithful to God’s call for believers.[13]
It is neither
honest nor wise to divorce discussion of these ongoing terror threats, from the
military actions of the US and Israel in fighting against these Middle Eastern
countries. Yes, Islamic terrorism is terrible. But if the Assad regime had not
been up against continued threat from rebels trained and equipped by western
forces, plus, according to Biden, direct attacks from the US at times, and
according to Trump the seizure of their oil which is a major Syrian resource[14], then these radical Islamist
groups would not have had the power to be persecuting the Christians in Syria
right now. There is a causal chain here, to ignore it is not an accurate analysis.
These wars
have caused incredible tragedies. For instance, Christianity has declined
massively in the Middle East because of the wars there. In Iraq, as of 2024,
the Christian population is one fifth of what it was in 2003 because of the
wars and ongoing persecution,
“Iraq’s
Christian population has drastically declined due to years of war and
persecution. From over 1.5 million in 2003, the number of Christians in Iraq
has dwindled to less than 300,000 today. Indigenous Christians, such as the
Assyrians, have suffered immensely, their communities uprooted, and their
ancient churches desecrated.”[15]
Persecution
of Christians did not begin with these wars, but it did escalate it. Even if - and
you can’t honestly argue this - but even if you said the US and Israel had good
intentions, their strategy to defeat evil in the Middle East has failed. They
have escalated it, incredibly. And they continue to do so. Christians who
advocate for more military intervention in the Middel East advocate for more of
the same bad actions. The more Israel and the US bomb the Middle East, the more
Christians are persecuted.
And as I have
already noted, these wars, have also caused a massive exodus of Muslims into
the West. Many of these Muslims have grievances, and many have done terrorist
attacks, especially in Europe. In fact, when you recognize this cycle, you
can’t unsee it:
So, I agree
100% that we need to fight Islamic terrorism, but not how we have been. We've
been making it worse. We should change how we fight it.
Firstly, we
should withdraw all military personnel from the Middle East and bring them back
home where we can police our own borders. Every western country has a problem
with too many people coming in. One of the historical roles of the military is
to police a nation’s, or people’s borders, when did this stop being their role?
I think it stopped when we got an elite who decided they did not really believe
in borders. An elite who believes the military exists to fight foreign wars. It
is evil.
We should
have incredibly strong militaries that police our own borders and are ready to
fight Islamic invasions or invasions from anyone else. No one here is calling
for pacifism. The US’s border is a mess. Our border feels like it is
effectively open by design. The largest number of new homes being bought in new
suburbs in Australia are from people overseas.[16], [17] and this is during a
homelessness crisis where many Australians can’t afford to buy a home. We
should be dialling down immigration massively, and every western country should
have strong militaries to protect their nations from invasion. Why is this so
complicated?
From a
Biblical perspective, we are also causing Israel to sin by fighting for it, anyway,
rather than pointing Israelis to trust in Jesus, the Lord God. As Isaiah said,
“1 Woe to those who go down to
Egypt for help, and rely on horses, who trust in chariots because they are
many, and in horsemen because they are very strong, but who do not look to the
Holy One of Israel, nor seek the Lord!” (Isa. 31:1).
So many
Christian Zionists say they take the Bible literally, but then ignore what it literally
says on a host of topics. Israel was commanded many times by God never to trust or ally with other
nations, but only
look to God. Is not Jesus God? As long as Israel has the US and others fighting
for it, we are creating a reason they don't need to call on Jesus. We are
causing them to sin. This needs to stop.
Secondly, a
lot of people need to go back. We have police agencies that can tackle
terrorism locally, but why do we keep making their job harder by creating more
problems for them with a continual stream of massive numbers of people?
Firstly, we should stop bringing in more people from troubled areas, and we
should send back those we can.
So, yes, we
need to fight Islamic terrorism, but not how we have been. We need to work much
smarter. And we need to stop stirring up the hornets’ nest of the Middle East
and bringing them here.
But now you
ask, how does this fit with theme of previous articles about how America is not
blessed by standing with Israel? That is simple, Jesus said,
“6
But whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in Me to sin, it would
be better for him if a millstone were hung around his neck, and he were drowned
in the depth of the sea. 7 Woe to the world because of offenses! For offenses
must come, but woe to that man by whom the offense comes!” (Matt. 18:6-7).
How much has
sin increased because of these wars? Particularly, how many people have been
turned off the gospel, because America is seen as a Christian country, but acts
in an antichrist way? American and Israeli wars have done more damage to the
witness of the gospel in the Middle East, than anything else I can think of in
history. This has caused great stumbling. No one who causes so many to stumble
can claim to be blessed. It is that simple.
List of
References
[10]
Ilan Pappe, 2024, Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic, One World
Publications, p.361
[11]
Ilan Pappe, 2024, p.348.